Everyone’s least favorite electric car manufacturer, Nio Inc (NYSE: NIO), is at it again. Yesterday they announced their long-awaited capital partnership with the local Hefei government; the stock promptly rallied 20%, before fading to close +10%. A closer look at the terms of the transaction, however, suggest a horrible deal for current ADR owners. I added to my short yesterday and think, best case, this restructuring implies ~$1.3/share for ADR owners, along with imminent and significant dilution. Let’s look at the announced terms:
I’ve highlighted the key points, which are essentially:
- new investors are putting in 7bn CNY cash;
- Nio Inc (current holdco) is putting in 4.3bn CNY cash;
- Nio Inc is contributing ‘its core businesses and assets in China’ – ie substantially all its assets;
- Nio Inc keeps 76% of Nio China whilst new investors get 24% of it;
- Valuation of these assets is assumed to be 17.8bn CNY, based upon the Nio Inc stock price (ie a circular valuation method unrelated to fundamental asset value);
- Over half of Nio Inc’s cash contribution is due by June 30 (2.55bn out of 4.3bn total);
- The asset transfer may only happen much later (up to a year after closing).
So what actually happened? Prima facie, the new investors are ending up with 24% of Nio’s business – through Nio China – for an injection of 7bn…therefore implying a total valuation for Nio China of 29bn CNY, or $4.1bn. That doesn’t sound too bad…right?
But remember Nio Inc – the topco that ADR holders own – still needs to contribute 4.3bn CNY cash as well. In other words, the amount of new money being taken in is only 2.7bn…and for that the new investors receive a 24% stake in Nio China. On this basis, the implied Nio China valuation is thus only 11.3bn CNY ($1.6bn)…and Nio only owns 76% of this number (that is, $1.2bn). Not so great…
There is another, more aggressive (in Nio’s favor) way to slice the valuation. Instead of netting the cash injections against each other, let’s simply work out the total assets of new Nio China and see what Nio Inc owns of that. Here is how it looks:
Here I’ve simply given Nio credit for the circular valuation of the Asset Consideration – based as it is upon the Nio Inc share price, ie, very generous – but the key is because Nio Inc still needs to inject 4.3bn cash AND has 8.4bn of remaining financial debt (remember all those converts?) the implied valuation of Nio Inc stock, pro-forma for this transaction, is still only $1.3/share. Also note that this analysis does nothing with the working capital deficit (3.5bn CNY at year end, potentially higher now), which has to go somewhere. Whether it goes with the business into Nio China, or stays at Nio Inc, that will need to be funded as well – obviously lowering ultimate value per share to the ADR. If working capital deficit rolled up to the ADR level alone, the shares would be worth only 80c/share…
This of course raises the obvious problem with the restructuring plan as announced: what happens to the existing Nio Inc financial debt? The words ‘debt’ or ‘liabilities’ were notably absent from Nio Inc’s press release, but given the imperatives of the Hefei government – job creation, manufacturing plant creation, building R&D knowhow, etc – I highly doubt they would structure this transaction in such a way if they were willing to take the >$1bn USD financial debt that Nio Inc has amassed and assume it. Instead, the rather tortuous structuring of this deal – and the time it has taken to emerge – suggests they are explicitly avoiding taking this burden.
Essentially, the Nio assets – and only the assets – are being carved out, to be recapitalized probably in conjunction with Nio delivering on its obligations to move to Hefei and invest locally. Meanwhile the existing financial (and perhaps operational) liabilities of Nio Inc are stranded at the ADR level – meaning mostly foreign shareholders (and bondholders) take the pain. Such an obvious asset transfer is only possible because optically the equity stake being granted to the new investors – 25% – is much lower than 50% and thus doesn’t constitute a Change in Control (which would trigger par repayment of Nio Inc’s existing converts).
But in reality this is still an asset stripping exercise, to the benefit of new Chinese money coming in and the detriment of all existing stock and bondholders in Nio Inc. The fact that the market cannot see how obvious this is – yet – only means that Nio Inc will clearly monetize the temporarily high price, through large and dilutive offerings, as they still need to fund ~$600mm of investment into Nio China in the very near term (by June 30); have <$100mm cash on hand today; and still are burning ~$80-100mm cash per month in the business. ADR owners/buyers should be wary before jumping in the pool here…
Disclosure: short NIO stock
10 thoughts on “Nio update: restructuring deal implies max $1.3/shr of ADR value…”
Assuming the debt remains on the NIO Inc entity, it effectively becomes a HoldCo for the liabilities and a 75% equity stake in NIO China. How would NIO Inc be able to service the interest and principal payments without direct cash flow? Would they be able to funnel cash flow from NIO China, or would this have to be in the form of regular dividends from NIO China to NIO Inc?
all excellent points. you are right, they would need to upstream some cash from China to holdco. Since there are no dividends to speak of, and this seems very unlikely to develop any time soon, I think it is more likely you see a continual sell-down by Inc of their residual China stake, to the Chinese partners. This may be another way the asset stripping is effected.
W/C must be subtracted either way. Even if NIO China picks it up, isn’t it 76% owned by the ADR anyway? In other words, -$380M best case?
very true. i was trying to be generous to the company…
I have only just today become aware of your blog due to your post on Metlife, a company that for me just keeps on giving. I have looked at Nio Inc chart and it forms a perfect bearish gartley, a harmonic pattern using Fibonacci ratios. I just thought you might be interested. Picture attached.
My math is like this. NIO ADR market cap today is about $3.5b. Add to that about $1b of debt plus $0.5b that is still required for the Hefei deal. So call it $5b EV. Divide that by 76% and you get $6.6b.
So if NIO China could be IPO’ed for anything higher than that, then the ADR is actually cheap. No?
hi Jeff – afraid you’re missing that Nio China takes all the assets, but none of the debt, that current exists at Nio Inc – and at the same time Nio Inc still has to contribute more cash (as you suggested). If all the debt stays with Nio shareholders (at Nio Inc) but they only have 76% of Nio China (and have to commit new capital), how can Nio Inc equity be worth anything close to where it currently trades.
Besides – Nio Inc book equity today is actually negative $1bn…
you can check out this tweet i sent out earlier, referencing the 20-F filings today, which shows how the Chinese are effectively asset stripping Nio Inc and leaving the foreign shareholders and bondholders holding worthless paper:
Thanks Jeremy for the prompt reply!
Not to be snarky, but I thought I did account for the fact that the debt stays at the ADR.
We can run this in reverse. If NIO China is worth $6.6b, then NIO Inc is worth 76% of that = $5b.
Minus $1.5b of debt (including what they have yet to inject into the newco) that gives us a market cap of $3.5b. What am I missing?
we can’t run it in reverse because your math is wrong. you can’t just divide the Nio EV today by 76% – it is meaningless. Nio owns 76% of the equity in Nio China…equity only. then they have whatever they have in other liabilities (probably most or all of the $1.5bn adjusted debt) against that. im not sure where you get this ‘Nio China is worth $6.6bn’ from but its an illusory number. The Chinese investors just valued all of Nio China at ~$4bn (and that itself was circular, based on Nio’s stock price, not net assets).